This is a goblet of blood from a cursed altar in a spooky secret basement room. It's probably safe and fine and good.
- The Altar Room in the cellar of the Stearns Ranch.
You can choose to give it to Grace or empty it.
- You can also throw it into the pit at the Jumbleneck Mine for 40 - 43 XP.
- in 'Reckonin' at gun manor' the play can opt to try giving the goblet to the ghost girl. However, she rejects it.